Certified Payroll Rejection Reasons and How to Fix Them

A certified payroll is a signed statement made under federal law, so a reviewer reads it line by line. When a required item is missing or the numbers do not agree with each other, the payroll gets questioned or sent back for correction. The gaps below are the ones that show up when a payroll is compared with the rule. Each one maps to a specific requirement in 29 CFR 5.5, so you can check your own payroll against the text. This is general information, not legal advice. Your contract, the wage determination, and your prime's instructions control.

The Statement of Compliance is missing, unsigned, or not true

The Statement of Compliance is the part that makes a payroll certified. Under 29 CFR 5.5(a)(3)(ii)(C), each certified payroll must come with one, and it states three things: the payroll contains the required information and the records behind it are correct and complete; every worker was paid full weekly wages with no rebates and no deductions other than permitted ones; and every worker was paid at least the required wage and fringe rates for the classification actually performed.

The signature must be an original handwritten signature or a legally valid electronic signature (paragraph (a)(3)(ii)(E)). The regulation also warns that falsifying a certification may subject you to civil or criminal prosecution under 18 U.S.C. 1001 and 31 U.S.C. 3729 (paragraph (a)(3)(ii)(F)).

The fix: sign only after you have checked that week's hours and rates against your records. Do not sign a blank form to be filled in later, and do not sign a statement you have not checked.

Worker identifiers are inconsistent, or the weekly shows a full Social Security number

The weekly payroll needs an individually identifying number for each worker, such as the last four digits of the Social Security number. Under 29 CFR 5.5(a)(3)(ii)(B), full Social Security numbers and last known addresses, telephone numbers, and email addresses must not be on the weekly submission. Those details still belong in your records. You must keep them and provide them when they are requested. A prime that asks for full numbers for its own file is a separate request from the weekly submission.

The fix: pick one identifier for each worker and use the same form every week. A worker who appears under two numbers, or under two spellings of the same name, is a reconciliation problem for the reviewer.

Classifications do not match the work or the wage determination

Your records must show each worker's correct classification for the work actually performed, and the rates paid must match the wage determination in the contract for that classification (29 CFR 5.5(a)(3)(i)(B)). The Statement of Compliance certifies the rate for the classification actually performed, so a title that does not fit the work is not a clerical matter.

The fix: read the wage determination before the job starts, and map each job title on your crew to a classification on it. If a title is not on the determination, ask the prime and the contracting officer how that work should be classified before you pay anyone under it. See what a wage determination is and Davis-Bacon Act basics for subcontractors.

Hours on the payroll do not match the daily reports

The records must show the daily and weekly hours actually worked, in total and on each covered contract (29 CFR 5.5(a)(3)(i)(B)). If your daily report shows ten hours on Tuesday and the payroll shows eight, the reviewer will ask which is right. The same question comes up when a worker is on the daily report but missing from the payroll, or when a payroll shows hours that no report records.

The fix: reconcile the payroll to the daily reports for the same week before you sign. Every hour on the payroll should trace back to a time record. See how to fill out a daily report.

Fringe benefits are blank or unexplained

The fringe rate in the wage determination is part of what you owe. The records must show the rates of contributions or costs for bona fide fringe benefits, and the records that show what those benefits cost (29 CFR 5.5(a)(3)(i)(B)–(C)). A blank fringe column with no explanation leaves a gap between the wage determination and the payroll, and the reviewer will ask about that gap.

The fix: show the fringe the way your plan works, whether that is cash, a bona fide plan, or both, and keep the plan documents and contribution records on file. See Davis-Bacon fringe benefits: cash vs. bona fide plans.

A checklist before you sign the weekly payroll

Certified payroll is submitted weekly, for each week in which covered work is performed (29 CFR 5.5(a)(3)(ii)(A)). Run each payroll through this list before you sign it.

  1. Statement of Compliance signed in original handwriting or a valid electronic signature, after the hours and rates were checked.
  2. One identifying number per worker, the same every week. No full Social Security number on the weekly submission.
  3. Every classification matches the work performed and the wage determination in the contract.
  4. Hours reconcile to the daily reports for the same week.
  5. Fringe is shown as cash, plan contributions, or both, with the plan records on file.
  6. Every week with covered work is submitted on time. Keep a dated note for any week without covered work.
  7. Records are kept for three years after all the work on the prime contract is completed (29 CFR 5.5(a)(3)(ii)(G)). See how long to keep certified payroll.

If a payroll is due this week, run it through the list before you sign. If you are new to certified payroll, start with certified payroll for subcontractors.

Learn the paperwork. Get connected to the buyers.

Federal Sub Academy teaches the SF 1413, the daily report, and certified payroll step by step. Enrollment is open now — $2,495.95 one time for the full program.

Not ready to enroll? Join the opening list. Hiring subcontractors? See the subcontractor directory.

Enroll now — $2,495.95 Student sign in

Get the free paperwork checklist

Get the free federal subcontract paperwork checklist — the core forms and records a federal subcontractor is asked to produce, on one page. We’ll email you the link.